Workforce Wonk

By Alyah Khan

Blog archive

The biggest threat to federal job security: death

Job security is one of the known benefits of federal employment. But, are federal jobs too secure?

A recent analysis by USA Today appears to answer that question with a resounding ‘yes.’

By researching the Office of Personnel Management’s database, the newspaper found that the job security rate for all federal workers was 99.43 percent last year and nearly 100 percent for those on the job more than a few years.

As a result, USA Today determined that some federal employees are more likely to die of natural causes than get laid off or fired.

“Death – rather than poor performance, misconduct or layoffs – is the primary threat to job security at the Environmental Protection Agency, the Small Business Administration, the Department of Housing and Urban Development, the Office of Management and Budget and a dozen other federal operations,” reporter Dennis Cauchon wrote in the article.

To critics of the federal workforce, this information only adds more fuel to the fire. For the last several months, feds have been targeted as lazy and overpaid.

But, let’s put aside those negative comments for a moment and think about what this analysis reveals about federal management. Clearly, poor performers aren’t being held accountable and they have the job security to prove it.

Government leaders, including OPM Director John Berry, continue to call for managers to set clear expectations for their employees and regularly assess their performance.

But, what will it really take for federal managers to get rid of team members who aren’t pulling their own weight? And what about managers who aren’t executing the agency’s mission and providing leadership? Who holds them accountable?

Posted by Alyah Khan on Jul 19, 2011 at 9:38 AM




 

Reader comments

Mon, Jan 30, 2012 Fort Wayne, Ind

My wife works for the Department of Veterans Affairs. She was working when she changed employment to go to the VA. Our son was in Iraq. It made her feel close to him. She is the kind of person that sets up the xmas tree at the VA, She donates knitted blankets to Veterans organization, and Vets love her. She was friends with a person they tried to fire. When they couldn't fire this person, the super turned to my wife for someone to fire. This super has violated every civil right you can imagine to fire my wife and may soon get away with it. I'm talking not allowing vacation, violating any and all union agreement rules. She even took my wifes doctors slips around the bospital and showed them to everyone. A veteran reported a secretary for slamming a phone against the wall and cussing. The super and the secretary turned it around on the veteran, saying he was unruly. A sad thing for our veterans.

Thu, Sep 1, 2011 PA

Federal employees outside Washington work 9-14 hours per day without compensation and we've been doing it for years. Was is going on elsewhere? Look to Washington to set the tone. Want to see a bull**** program, look to the Ttile 32 AGRs. 30 days leave per year, sick leave with free health care, a 20 year retirement, non-taxable BAS and BHA on top of base pay, passes and Federal holidays, and left at armories doing sports, internet or TV all day, and hiring on the good ole boy system. Now there's good graft and corruption.

Fri, Jul 29, 2011 fed-up USA

I've been working in DoD for the past 6 years after working for a Fortune 500 company for 8. I see the validity in this article every day. Granted, it may just be my situation (doubt it). It's bad enough to see some employees get by with what they are doing but it's even worse when the supervisor turns their head (and just wait until the supervisor goes on leave). I question if I want to take the next step and go into management. While it's difficult to separate a federal employee, I hear its rather easy to let a new supervisor go for EEO complaints when they are trying to "encourage" the adults they have working for them to be anything but reactionary. I believe that the high number of retired soldiers in the federal workforce discovered "way back when" that all-in-all a federal employee has it made. Great job security, good benefits, a decent wage, they already had an advantage over anybody who has never served, and a retired soldier is not double-dipping with a government job(?). Please know I hold the up-most respect for our men and women in uniform, that's why I pursued federal service. I just get really down when I see the level of complacency I'm surrounded with. I'd like to make a difference but with turnover the way it is, I guess I'll have to wait for retirements (which I understand are going to be picking way up over the next 10 years) or ... well you know the other. Maybe after another 6 years I'll be over this culture shock. I regret if this is offensive to anyone but sometimes writing your thoughts relieves anxiety. We'll see.

Mon, Jul 25, 2011

I have been a Civil Service employee, since retiring from the military in 2006. I truly believe that 99% of the federal workforce do perform their duties exceptionally well in support of the warfighter. There will always be that 1% who should have been let go years ago or not promoted. I believe the federal workforce is surely not the problem. The focus should be on the two groups who are constantly lining their pockets or simply jocking for political gain. Politicians and Federal Contractors are the root cause and the price is paid by the blood spilled from or armed forces and what now seems to be on the backs of the honest working federal employee.

Mon, Jul 25, 2011 Danny Branch Washington

I have grown tired of these relentless reports about how lazy and unless Federal employees are. We have been on the forfront for years in support of our nation, it citzens and the war fight. We hire these politicians who spend our money anyway they want and when the money runs out the blame game begins. We will consistently have the type of finacial problems we currently experience until we make the officials we hire accountable. We need checks and balance to ensure that our money is spend proper and wishly.

Show All Comments

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Your Name:(optional)
Your Email:(optional)
Your Location:(optional)
Comment:
Please type the letters/numbers you see above