Workforce Wonk

By Alyah Khan

Blog archive

Gender and job satisfaction in the federal government

Do women feds feel as satisfied with their jobs as their male colleagues?

For the most part, it appears that they do. However, there are still gaps in how men and women perceive their work environment, according to data released May 25 by the Partnership for Public Service.

The Partnership’s “Best Places to Work in the Federal Government” snapshot examined workplace differences among men and women.

Based on the Office of Personnel Management’s 2010 employee survey, the Partnership concluded that women are slightly less satisfied than men in nine out of 10 workplace categories and slightly more satisfied in only one category – skills/mission match.

The biggest disparity between men and women related to empowerment and fairness – such as whether employees feel involved with decisions – in the effective leadership category. Women gave the lowest score, compared with men, to the survey question about fear of reprisal for disclosing suspected violations.

Overall, men rated the effective leadership category a score of 57.1 (out of 100), while women rated it 54.6.

Women in management positions appear to face another problem: work/life balance. The survey indicated that women managers were less satisfied in this category than men in management by 2.4 points.

So, what does all this mean and why is it important?

“Today, women are half the labor marker and fill a growing number of management and professional jobs,” the Partnership explained. “Managing the workforce of tomorrow will require leaders to tap the potential of all employees, men and women.”

Sure, the government has done a good job of integrating women into its workforce, but it seems that some agencies have work to do when it comes to making the federal playing field equal for all.

What do you think about the satisfaction gaps among men and women feds? How do you think the government could improve? Do you agree with the survey’s results? Why or why not?

Posted by Alyah Khan on May 25, 2011 at 1:23 PM




 

Reader comments

Thu, Jun 16, 2011

I am sure its lower scores in reality for women. Disparity has been studied to death, and we all know that Women, especially those over 40 are ignored for a place in the management ranks in the federal government. Case in point? I work at the USDA and have read the Jackson Lewis report on Women disparity in their workforce. Need I say more, Partnership for Public Service?

Wed, Jun 15, 2011

Satisfaction gaps have to do with feeling "included". The Balance of accepting and hearing women's ideas is still an issue....ask Brooksley Born! There is a reason God made men and women, it is not always about "Money and Power" (like the men seem to create). Being in touch with both the male and female side of themselves might be a start. The approach is mostly about "we've always done it this way", with little willingness for openmindedness. Women have had to "change", men have pretty much just had to "accept" that women are in the workplace, with little to no "conscious" effort on their part to "balance" the ying/yang of the situation. The way "men" have done it in history, has dug us deep into many unecesssary holes. Have we learned from history, or the mistakes...doesn't appear so, maybe it's time we "hear" what women have to say, to bring balance to our world before it's too late.....bottom line; it's not all about money and power,& who wins... it's about finding balance! We are all "creators of our reality", what you believe is what you get!!

Thu, May 26, 2011 The Observer

The reality is that the scores are probably lower. Those that are affected the most through workplace imbalances typically do not fill out surveys because they do not believe that any change will occur. If some has, the results should be posted.

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Your Name:(optional)
Your Email:(optional)
Your Location:(optional)
Comment:
Please type the letters/numbers you see above